Terry is an amazing attorney. If you are looking for the best, look no further! He is precise, professional and extremely easy to work with.

– Tammy F.

3 weeks ago

– Andy

3 weeks ago

Norma is the best !!!! She is very compassionate and takes your problems as her own! Her background as a persecutor Allows her to navigate your case in the best possible way! Norma, Thank you very much for everything! Tatyana

– Breez O.

4 weeks ago

– Elijah T.

3 weeks ago

St. Johns County Criminal Defense Attorneys

Successfully Helping Clients Beat Criminal Offenses

If you’ve been charged with a crime in St. Johns County, it’s essential to have a criminal defense attorney who understands the local courts, prosecutors, and procedures. At Shoemaker Law, we represent individuals facing criminal charges across northeast Florida. Whether you’re accused of a misdemeanor offense or a serious felony, your future is on the line—and our law firm is here to help protect it.

We work with clients through every stage of the legal process, including arrest, arraignment, plea negotiations, trial, and post-conviction matters. Our defense strategy focuses on identifying weaknesses in the prosecution’s evidence and presenting relevant evidence to support your case. We proudly serve the residents of St. Augustine and the greater St. Johns County area, offering zealous representation backed by extensive trial experience. Our dedicated team of St. Johns County criminal defense attorneys will review the facts of your case, offer honest legal advice, and defend you with integrity and commitment. Whether it’s a case of self-defense or a misunderstanding, we’ll make sure your side of the story is heard.

How May We Help You?

At Shoemaker Law, we handle a variety of criminal defense cases, providing clients with a robust legal defense.

Assault & Battery

DUI Defense

Felony DUI

Sex Crimes

Drug Crimes

Record Sealing & Expungement

Assault & Battery

DUI Defense

Felony DUI

Underage DUI

Drug Crimes

Record Sealing & Expungement

VIEW ALL PRACTICE AREAS

Building a Strong Defense Against Criminal Charges

Navigating criminal law requires more than just knowledge of the statutes—it takes experience, strategy, and a commitment to safeguarding your rights. Our criminal defense lawyers have successfully handled a wide range of criminal cases, including drug crimes and DUI cases. Whether your case involves misdemeanor charges or felony offenses, we tailor each defense strategy to the unique facts of the case.

Every allegation deserves fair treatment and due process. That’s why we gather evidence, review the prosecution’s case for errors, and push back against harsher penalties when they’re not warranted. As a former prosecutor, our lead attorney understands how the State Attorney’s Office prepares its cases—and uses that insight to your advantage. Let us help you pursue a favorable outcome while defending your legal interests with precision and care.

Client Success Stories

So, I had an event happen to me that I would have never expected. A truly bad event. Next thing I know I’m looking for a lawyer because I didn’t know how to handle or navigate anything that involves being in trouble/falsely accused.

– Jordan G.

Norma was super professional and was able to get all the charges against me dismissed. Throughout the process the communication was great and motions filed in my case showed that I was clearly innocent. I kept my mouth shut and let Norma do all the negotiating with the judge and prosecutor with her 30 years of experience. The state dropped all charges against me when it became clear the court made an error and the prosecution didn’t have a leg to stand on.

– Andy.

Terry is a very thorough attorney. He was able to accomplish what other attorneys said was impossible. I do and will continue to recommend Terry Shoemaker!

– Tim P.

Shoemaker and his team are precise, timely, and extremely easy to work with. If there is one place not to cut corners it’s choosing who represents you, this is the place that will help you when you need it the absolute most. Met and exceeded my expectations and I could relax knowing that I had the best representation I could get.

– Elijah T.

VIEW ALL REVIEWS

Local Knowledge Matters in St. Johns County Criminal Cases

Every county has its own way of handling criminal defense cases, and St. Johns County is no different. Our familiarity with local court procedures, judges, and the community at large gives us a significant advantage when defending clients in this region. Whether you’re facing assault charges in St. Augustine or a probation violation elsewhere in St. Johns County, we understand how to approach your case in a way that reflects local expectations.

We’re also well-versed in plea deals and formal review hearings, particularly in cases involving administrative suspension of driver’s licenses or blood alcohol level disputes. When your freedom and future are on the line, having a local criminal defense attorney with insight into the St. Johns County criminal court system can make all the difference. Call today to speak with our law office about your legal options.

Meet Our Team

Terry J. Shoemaker

DUI Defense and Criminal Law

Norma Wendt

Prosecutor and Criminal
Defense Attorney

Gay Durand

Paralegal

ABOUT US

Defense for a Range of Felony and Misdemeanor Offenses

Shoemaker Law handles everything from misdemeanor offenses to serious felonies in St. Johns County. If you’ve been arrested for aggravated assault, drunk driving, domestic violence, or drug trafficking, you need an experienced attorney who can navigate complex criminal defense cases. We routinely defend clients against charges like aggravated battery, violation of probation, intentional threat, and failure to register as a sex offender.

Our goal is to secure the best possible result—whether through presenting evidence at trial, negotiating plea agreements, or pursuing record sealing when appropriate. We don’t treat your case as just another file; we approach every defense with urgency, respect, and a firm grasp of Florida law. No matter the nature of your alleged crime, we’re prepared to defend your rights and help you understand every step of the legal process.

Why Choose Us?

Experienced Legal Team

Shoemaker Law has years of experience defending clients against a wide range of criminal charges. Our criminal defense team is well-versed in navigating the complexities of different criminal cases, ensuring you receive the best possible defense strategy based on our extensive legal knowledge and courtroom success.

Personalized Approach

At Shoemaker Law, we understand that every case is unique. We provide tailored legal strategies that align with your specific circumstances. Our attorneys take the time to understand your case fully, ensuring a customized defense that addresses all aspects of your criminal charges effectively.

Strong Negotiators

Our team at Shoemaker Law is known for negotiating favorable settlements on behalf of our clients. We work diligently to secure the best possible outcome, often reducing charges or penalties through strategic negotiations. Our goal is to achieve the best result while minimizing the impact of the charges.

Aggressive Representation

In the courtroom, Shoemaker Law fights relentlessly for our clients’ rights. We don’t back down when advocating for you. Our attorneys are aggressive, ensuring that your case is thoroughly presented, witnesses are questioned, and all evidence is challenged to get the best possible result for your defense.

Client-Focused Services

Shoemaker Law prioritizes our clients’ needs, providing compassionate and understanding legal services throughout the process. We believe in supporting you not just legally, but emotionally, ensuring you feel heard and understood every step of the way. Your concerns are our top priority as we work on your behalf.

Proven Track Record

Shoemaker Law has a history of success in defending criminal cases in St. Johns County. Our proven track record of favorable outcomes speaks to our knowledge and dedication. We have consistently secured reduced charges, favorable verdicts, and dismissed cases for our clients over the years.

Avoid Life-Changing Consequences of a Criminal Conviction

A criminal conviction in St. Johns County can have devastating effects beyond any jail time or fines imposed by the court. Depending on the nature of the offense, you could face harsher penalties like probation, administrative suspension of your driver’s license, or mandatory registration for certain crimes. Even misdemeanor charges can impact your ability to secure housing, employment, or professional licensing under Florida law. For felony offenses, the consequences are even more severe, including loss of civil rights like voting and firearm ownership.

In many cases, a conviction becomes part of your permanent criminal record, visible to future employers, landlords, and background check systems. If you hold a professional license or government job, your career could be at risk. Immigration consequences may also apply if you’re not a U.S. citizen. Our Florida criminal defense attorneys work to protect your legal interests, mitigate penalties, and pursue every opportunity to avoid conviction or minimize its long-term impact. Don’t face the prosecution’s case alone—call today for a free consultation.

Our Latest Blog Posts

November 1, 2025

The Role of Digital Evidence in St. Augustine Sex Crime Cases

In today’s connected world, our lives leave a digital trail. From text messages and emails to social media posts and location check-ins, nearly every action can be recorded. When someone in St. Augustine is accused of a sex crime, this digital footprint often becomes a central part of the investigation and prosecution. Understanding how digital evidence is used in St. Johns County courtrooms is crucial for anyone facing these serious allegations. This evidence can feel overwhelming and absolute, but it is rarely that simple. Messages can be taken out of context, data can be misinterpreted, and the evidence collection process…

The Role of DNA Evidence in St. Augustine Murder Trials

Understanding the Role of DNA Evidence in St. Augustine Murder Trials Investigating serious crimes in St. Johns County often involves the meticulous collection and analysis of evidence. Among the most powerful tools available to both prosecutors and defense attorneys in St. Augustine murder trials is deoxyribonucleic acid, or DNA evidence. Its ability to uniquely identify individuals has revolutionized criminal justice, but…

How Do Florida’s Three Strikes Laws Impact Repeat Offenders in St. Augustine?

Have You Been Arrested For the Same Offense Again? The “three-strikes” rule has become a popular law among many states, including Florida. This set of laws is meant to deter people from committing serious crimes multiple times with ever-increasing punishments, up to the possibility of life in prison. The issue is, sometimes the cops get it wrong. Just because you have…

Protecting Your Rights During an Arrest in St. Augustine

Are You Afraid of Getting Arrested? It is understandable to be afraid of getting arrested, especially by an overzealous cop on a power trip. Unfortunately, many people are unaware of their rights when dealing with the cops. They are also unfamiliar with tactics cops use to back them into a corner and incite behavior or comments that allow them to place…

The Role of Digital Evidence in St. Augustine Sex Crime Cases

In today’s connected world, our lives leave a digital trail. From text messages and emails…

The Role of DNA Evidence in St. Augustine Murder Trials

Understanding the Role of DNA Evidence in St. Augustine Murder Trials Investigating serious crimes in…

How Do Florida’s Three Strikes Laws Impact Repeat Offenders in St. Augustine?

Have You Been Arrested For the Same Offense Again? The “three-strikes” rule has become a…

Protecting Your Rights During an Arrest in St. Augustine

Are You Afraid of Getting Arrested? It is understandable to be afraid of getting arrested,…

How Can You Challenge Evidence in a St. Augustine Criminal Case?

What Should I Do If I Am Charged With a Crime? If you have been…

What to Expect After a DUI Arrest in St. Augustine

What Is Considered a DUI in Florida? DUI, which stands for driving under the influence,…

VIEW ALL BLOGS

Start Building Your Defense Today with an Experienced Criminal Defense Attorney

You don’t have to face criminal charges alone. Shoemaker Law offers a free consultation to individuals throughout Johns County, including St. Augustine and surrounding communities, facing criminal offenses. Whether you’re facing prosecution for DUI manslaughter, drug crimes, assault charges, or probation violations, we’ll walk you through your options and develop a defense strategy aligned with your circumstances, and navigate your case through the criminal justice system.

Contact Our St. Johns County Criminal Defense Attorneys

With years of trial experience and a strong understanding of criminal law, our law office provides clear guidance and effective legal representation for all types of criminal charges. From violent crimes with aggravating factors to felony cases, we advocate for your rights from arrest through resolution—whether by dismissal, negotiating plea deals, or courtroom litigation. Let us help you challenge the prosecution’s evidence and pursue fair treatment under Florida law.

Frequently Asked Questions

What should I do if I’m arrested in St. Johns County?

If you’re arrested, remain calm and assert your right to remain silent. Do not answer questions or make statements to the police without a criminal defense attorney present. Anything you say can be used against you. Contact an experienced attorney as soon as possible to begin protecting your rights and developing a defense strategy. At Shoemaker Law, we provide free consultations and immediate guidance. Our firm will evaluate your charges, communicate with the State Attorney’s Office, and work to preserve key evidence. Acting quickly can be the difference between a dismissal and a conviction.

What are the penalties for a felony conviction in Florida?

Felony convictions in Florida carry serious, life-altering penalties. Depending on the degree of the felony and whether aggravating factors exist, you could face years—or even life—in prison, massive fines, and probation. In addition, a felony record may impact your civil rights, including your ability to vote or possess firearms. Professional licenses and immigration status may also be at risk. Our experienced criminal defense attorneys fight to avoid these outcomes by identifying weaknesses in the prosecution’s case, presenting evidence in your favor, and negotiating plea deals when appropriate to secure the most favorable outcome possible.

Can I avoid jail time if I’m charged with a misdemeanor?

Many first-time or low-level misdemeanor offenses may be resolved without jail time. Alternatives such as probation, community service, counseling, or diversion programs may be available, especially if there are no aggravating factors. A criminal defense attorney can advocate for reduced charges or a non-custodial sentence by highlighting your clean record, employment history, and other mitigating circumstances. At Shoemaker Law, we evaluate every option to protect your record and minimize disruption to your life. Even though misdemeanors are less serious than felonies, they can still result in fines, license suspension, and other long-term consequences without proper legal representation.

What is the difference between a DUI and DUI manslaughter charge?

A standard DUI involves driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs and is typically charged as a misdemeanor, though it can escalate depending on prior convictions. DUI manslaughter, however, is a second-degree felony and occurs when a person under the influence causes a crash that results in death. Penalties may include up to 15 years in prison, a permanent criminal record, and revocation of your driver’s license. If you’re facing DUI or DUI manslaughter charges in St. Johns County, contact Shoemaker Law immediately. Our defense attorneys will review the evidence, including your blood alcohol level and any formal review hearings.

What happens if I violate probation in St. Johns County?

Violating probation can result in a warrant for your arrest and a hearing where the judge may revoke probation and impose your original sentence. Common violations include failing drug tests, missing meetings with a probation officer, or being arrested for new charges. The consequences vary based on the violation’s severity and your criminal history. A criminal defense lawyer can advocate for reinstatement of probation or a modified sentence. Shoemaker Law represents clients facing probation violations and works to present mitigating evidence, negotiate with prosecutors, and protect your freedom and future.

Can a criminal record be sealed or expunged in Florida?

Yes, certain charges may qualify for record sealing or expungement under Florida law. If your case was dismissed or you were acquitted, you may be eligible to have your record expunged. If you completed a diversion program, you may also qualify. Sealing a record limits who can view it, while expungement removes it entirely from public databases. However, not all offenses are eligible. Our law firm reviews your eligibility, files the appropriate petitions, and guides you through the legal process so you can pursue a clean slate and move forward without the burden of a public criminal record.

How can a criminal defense attorney challenge the prosecution’s case?

A strong defense strategy starts by identifying weaknesses in the prosecution’s evidence. This may include questioning the legality of a traffic stop, filing motions to suppress evidence, or challenging the credibility of witnesses. Defense attorneys may also gather evidence, consult experts, and present alternative narratives to create reasonable doubt. In many cases, early intervention can lead to dropped or reduced charges. Shoemaker Law’s defense attorneys use extensive trial experience and legal insight to protect your rights and challenge the State Attorney’s case at every step—whether through pre-trial motions, plea negotiations, or trial advocacy.

How long does a criminal case usually take in St. Johns County?

The length of a criminal case in St. Johns County varies depending on the type and complexity of the charges. A simple misdemeanor may resolve in a few weeks through plea negotiations, while serious felonies could take several months or even over a year if they proceed to trial. Factors like court scheduling, motions, discovery, and the availability of witnesses all impact timelines. At Shoemaker Law, we prioritize efficiency while ensuring a thorough defense. From the initial arraignment through each court date, our legal team works to move your case forward while protecting your rights at every step.

Get a Free Consultation

Quick. No Obligation. Confidential.